On September 22nd, 2007, I got together with several of my friends (Eve Phillips, Jocelyn Joy Berl, Travis Kalanick, Nathan Schmidt, and Alan Keefer) and with the inspiration of my brother Chris Weekly we tasted a number of beers and rated them, along with commentary. They’re ranked here from top scoring to bottom scoring as averaged by all six individual scores. All scores are on a scale of 10.
Boddington’s (7.6)
- smooth, creamy, balanced
- i love it, wow
- it’s got “twang”
- clean finish, doesn’t linger
- quickly drinkable, goes down fast
- classically styled
Smithwick’s (7.1)
- very full-bodied, smooth beer
- mature, nothing up front, everything on the back end
- the trojan horse of beers
- almost “woodsy” not quite “floury”
Hen’s Tooth (6.6)
- malty musky
- bitter, sour, strong, “leather and coffee”
- could drink some amount of it
St. Peter’s Golden Ale (6.5)
- hoppy head, barley ass
- a little honeyed
- burnt toast, lingering
- a long finish
- citrusy like a bitter orange
St. Peter’s English Ale (6.0)
- hoppy, tart, smooth/subtle
- bready, easy to drink
Murphy’s Irish Red [in glass] (5.8)
- lacking in personality
- “the guy with pec implants”
- not at all what i would expect from an “irish red”,
this is an “irish pink”
- “almost great…but it misses”
- got a little “snap” to it
- sourdoughy, herby, tart, “sunny like a picnic”
- good picnic beer, cheerful / inoffensive
- “let’s play some volleyball”
Hobgoblin [wychwood brewery] (5.0)
- fruity, citrusy, “early bitterball”, a “clean exit”
- “this is almost a fruit juice”
- heavy, but doesn’t stick around
- wouldn’t want to drink a lot of it, “4 oz and i’m done”
Killian’s (5.0)
- transition beer from “not beer to beer”
- musty, “horsey”, “hay, urine, and dust”
- sparkly, not a lot of taste, bland
- “would not call in the morning”
- “meh”
- olivey
- a “bar beer”, “not a gourmet beer”
- velvety, soft, a little fruity / apple juice
Miller Lite (3.8)
- “club soda redone as beer”
- “it’s really nothing”
- inoffensive, simple
- watery
- “an inch and a half of roots showing”
- “trailer trash beer”
Belhaven “Wee Heavy” (3.4)
- nice color
- “something is wrong with this beer”
- eve WINCED – bitter & chocolatey “like a triple boch”
- rancid chocolate
- “it smells of feet…and not my feet”
- “over the top on every category”
- “italian chimay”
- strong attitude
- sweet, bitter, sour vanilla with chocolate
- “bridge and tunnel”